scoring-impact-rubric

ARCHIVED

"I'm not trying to eliminate my scoring, just edit it. […] So what's left are scores serving as proxy for the strength of the idea's personal, social, and business impact." — Katy, 2026-08-14 "lets use the openspec framework - dogfooding!" — Katy, kicking off this change, 2026-08-14

STAGES

  1. proposal08-16
  2. requirements08-16
  3. design08-16
  4. tasks08-16
  5. build—
  6. archived08-16

CAPABILITY

  • experiment-impact-scoring5 requirements

OUTCOMES — AND HOW EACH IS MEASURED

  • ✓1.1**Rubric store rewritten** — reading the scoring rules and archive skill shows only the three-proxy rubric (1–5 each, total 3–15) with a matching re-grade line format; no active Mission/Pull/Speed or platformCost/TAM-anchor language remains in store filesnot stated
  • ✓1.2**Impact profile renders** — an impact-scored experiment's detail page shows the `IMPACT SCORE n/15` heading and the Personal / Social / Business / History tab bar with score badges; the selected tab renders its full justification (a paragraph or a whole business case, structure preserved) at both breakpoints, and the landing badge shows `n/15`not stated
  • ✓1.3**V1-only experiment renders unchanged** — a v1-only experiment's landing badge shows its `n/25` total as today, labeled as the v1 historical record; no five-dimension display is introduced or revivednot stated
  • ✓1.4**Every shape combination is safe** — experiments with new-only, v1-only, both, partial, and no scores all render their correct display with no runtime errorsnot stated
  • ✓1.5**Totals computed per shape** — new-shape totals land in 3–15, v1 totals in 5–25, partial scores yield no total, and no tooltip hardcodes "/25 … see /scoring"not stated
  • ✓1.6**Impact-scored Notion row syncs** — filling the three score columns (and optionally writing `Why:` child pages) on a Labs database row puts the scores, justifications, and total on the hub; the new shape wins when v1 columns are also fillednot stated
  • ✓1.7**Doc pages and links are gone** — `/scoring`, `/heuristics`, and `/harness` return the app's not-found response and nothing in the header or landing page links to themnot stated

WHAT HAPPENED

  1. ARCHIVED

    proposal and specs and design and tasks and archive landed

    2026-08-16 · 1 pull request
    • #378chore(openspec): archive scoring-impact-rubric as SHIPPED

History read from a manifest built at 2026-09-30 (09e7bcc).

1 pull request, found by commits touching the change folder